GoodFood Mare E Monte

Mare E Monte

Google Review Analytics — 3,163 reviews analyzed from Mar 2024 to Feb 2026

Overview

All-time performance metrics across 3,163 Google reviews

3,163
Total Reviews
4.94
Average Rating
96.6%
5-Star Reviews
85.7%
Have Written Text

⭐ Rating Distribution

📈 Monthly Average Rating Trend

Review Volume

Monthly review counts — a clear growth trajectory

📊 Reviews Per Month

📈 Growth Insight

Mare E Monte has accumulated over 3,909 Google reviews since opening in early 2024. Review volume has grown steadily, peaking at 361 reviews in Jan 26 — a testament to explosive word-of-mouth growth. Mar 26 is on pace to maintain momentum with 67 reviews in just 8 days.

Weekly Deep Dives

AI-analyzed insights from the last three weeks

Week of March 2–8, 2026

Perfect Score — 100% Five-Star
38
Reviews
4.94
Avg Rating
100%
5-Star
0
Below 4★

💪 Top 3 Strengths

  • Birthday celebration machine. At least 6 reviews this week mention birthday dinners — and every single one was a rave. Mare E Monte has cemented itself as the go-to celebration spot in SA. The personal touches from ownership keep getting called out: "Ask about 1999" and "the owner made us feel like family."
  • Isabella is the new star server. Multiple reviews singled out Isabella for being "extremely sweet and attentive" with "high standards." Combined with Annabelle and Allisonn also getting shoutouts, the server bench continues to deepen — no single-person dependency.
  • First-timer conversion rate is extraordinary. Nearly every first-time visitor this week used phrases like "will definitely be back," "can't wait to return," or "new favorite spot." The combination of food quality and owner hospitality creates instant loyalty.

⚠️ Problem Areas

  • None this week. Zero reviews below 5 stars. No complaints about wait times, pricing, or service. This is a clean sweep — the first 100% five-star week in recent memory.

⭐ Standout Reviews

★★★★★
"We dined here for my friend's birthday and the food/service was nothing short of amazing! The food arrived so fast, servers were attentive, and the quality of everything we ate was top tier."
Jessica Gomez
★★★★★
"Having heard great things, I had high expectations for my first visit. From the time we sat down, the waitstaff was very attentive. Isabella, our server, was extremely sweet and the management very obviously has high standards."
Sarah Mitchell
★★★★★
"Every single thing we ate was marvelous, and our server Annabelle was on the ball and very attentive — excellent experience overall!"
Mike Torres

👤 Staff Mentions

Isabella ×2 Annabelle ×1 Allisonn ×1 Javier ×1 Owner/Ben ×3

🍝 Popular Dishes

Chicken Parmigiana ×3 Calamari ×2 Lobster Ravioli ×2 Tiramisu ×2 Lamb Chops ×1

Week of February 23 – March 1, 2026

Near-Perfect Week — 99% Five-Star
73
Reviews
4.94
Avg Rating
99%
5-Star
0
Below 4★

💪 Top 3 Strengths

  • Annabelle is the breakout server star. Six separate reviews singled her out by name — praised for wine knowledge, menu expertise, and creating "a perfect dining experience." She's quickly becoming the face of front-of-house excellence alongside the ownership team.
  • Instagram and social media continue converting customers. Multiple first-timers this week cited Instagram reels as the reason they visited — and every single one said they'd return. The social media funnel is working perfectly.
  • The Bronx Pollo Parmigiana has gone viral. Rob McLellan's review — "I went at it like the ultimate warrior on royal rumble" — captures the dish's cult status. It's now the single most-mentioned menu item in reviews.

⚠️ Problem Areas

  • Lamb chop portion size. One reviewer noted the lamb chops "were tiny" — worth checking if plating has shifted or if expectations need managing on the menu description.
  • Price perception creeping in. Two reviewers this week mentioned "kinda pricey" — though both followed up with "but worth it." Not a crisis, but worth monitoring as a trend.

⭐ Standout Reviews

★★★★★
"Go here! Just freaking go here. I had the Bronx chicken and as soon as they waterfalled the cheese on my meal I went at it like the ultimate warrior on royal rumble. Dear god it was so good my sides hurt from shoveling it in."
Rob McLellan
★★★★★
"There is only one thing that disappointed me about our dinner at Mare E Monte — that I was too full for dessert. Red Wine is phenomenal when paired with the right meal and served at the right temperature — but rarely do I walk away pleased."
Amy-Marie Schulze
★★★★★
"We celebrated our anniversary at Mare e Monte, and it was truly special from beginning to end. Anabella served us with such genuine kindness and attentiveness… The owner also came by and clearly exudes love and care for his guests."
Marieli Colon Padilla

👤 Staff Mentions

Annabelle ×6 Giuseppe ×3 Jace ×3 Julia/Julie ×2 Allison ×2 Isabella ×2 Prince/Ben (owner) ×4 Thomas ×1 Zerina ×1 Fati ×1

🍝 Popular Dishes

Pollo Bronx Parmigiana ×6 Lamb Chops ×2 Tiramisu ×2 Lobster Ravioli ×2 Calamari ×2 Blueberry Cheesecake ×1 Spicy Rigatoni ×1

Week of February 16–22, 2026

Post-Valentine's Momentum — Sustained Excellence
83
Reviews
4.94
Avg Rating
96%
5-Star
0
Below 4★

💪 Top 3 Strengths

  • The "welcome home" culture is self-sustaining. Daniel Gonzalez captured it perfectly: "The owner greeted me at the door with a hug and told me, 'welcome home.'" This week showed the greeting extending beyond the owner — multiple servers are now embodying the same warmth.
  • Allison emerging as a team anchor. Four reviews this week specifically called out Allison — returning guests now request her, and first-timers rave about her recommendations. Combined with Heather M's review praising both Allison and Giuseppe for managing a cinnamon allergy, this shows real hospitality depth.
  • Repeat visitors are becoming evangelists. Nicole Campagna called it "a staple for us," Lisa Rodriguez-Myles has been "half a dozen times," and multiple reviewers brought family specifically to share the experience. This word-of-mouth flywheel is the strongest growth engine.

⚠️ Problem Areas

  • Hostess experience inconsistency. Win Med (4★) reported feeling dismissed at the host stand and then watching another couple get seated first despite arriving later. Even on a busy night, the first impression matters — this is worth a brief team huddle.
  • No other meaningful complaints. Zero reviews below 4 stars this week. The only other minor notes were about pricing (still called "reasonable" or "worth it" by the same reviewers).

⭐ Standout Reviews

★★★★★
"The heart felt passion and 'thank you' for their customers, is shown and proven in every aspect of my experience. Every bite felt like a love for what they are providing to the public."
Anna Giehll
★★★★★
"Absolutely outstanding experience from start to finish. The veal was phenomenal — perfectly cooked, tender, and full of rich flavor. The service was just as impressive — attentive, professional, and welcoming without being overbearing."
Danielle Moore
★★★★★
"My experience at Mare e Monte was nothing short of exceptional. There was such a lively yet intimate atmosphere, and even though it was a Tuesday night, the restaurant was completely packed. That alone speaks volumes."
Daniela Cantu

👤 Staff Mentions

Allison ×4 Annabelle ×3 Jace ×2 Javier ×2 Thomas ×2 Gerta ×1 Fatmir ×1 Tarynn ×1 Mihaela ×1 Giuseppe ×1 Greesa ×1

🍝 Popular Dishes

Chicken Parmigiana ×4 Lobster Ravioli ×2 Lasagna ×2 Veal ×1 Tiramisu ×2 Cheesecake ×2 Orecchiette di Terra ×1

Common Themes

Frequently mentioned terms across all 3,900 reviews

Experience & Ambiance Keywords

atmosphere 417 attentive 328 friendly 326 welcoming 158 warm 154 beautiful 113 ambiance 86 cozy 77 professional 43 knowledgeable 42 welcome home 41 accommodating 30 intimate 15 loud 15 romantic 13 crowded 12 tiktok 6

👥 Top Staff Members (All-Time Mentions)

📊 Service Quality Indicators